The most important characteristic of a learner is effort. In order to ensure the continuation of effort, it must be recognized and reinforced. Students will not realize the importance of effort unless they are taught about its importance (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn & Malenoski, 2007). There are predesigned effort checklists that can assist students in learning what the definition of effort is (Saphier, 2008). I adapted materials from an educational resource book to create a math effort checklist. I distributed this chart at my first math data grade level meeting. I need to follow through to see if teachers are using it. It is much more simplistic than the one in our text since I am in an elementary school setting (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn & Malenoski, 2007). The effort checklist can be introduced through shaping (Orey, 2001). One characteristic can be taught at a time and then more may be added to the chart a little bit at a time (Orey, 2001). I thought the graphing and keeping track of the effects of effort were exceptional, however I do not visualize that working well in elementary school. The checklist I developed, however, would serve as an excellent self-monitoring tool for students in third and fourth grade. When students can understand and experience the value of effort, they will put forth more effort and have more success with their learning. Initially, students will need praise and other extrinsic rewards to reinforce their effort. According to the behaviorist learning theory, these will be the positive reinforcement (Laureate Education, 2009a). The positive reinforcement is what increases the likelihood that a behavior will be repeated. Eventually, as students internalize the value of effort and the effects on their grades and learning, intrinsic motivation will take over and praise or extrinsic rewards may no longer be necessary. Lessons that incorporate technology are interesting to students. The interest level increases students’ desire to put more effort into working hard and doing well since they are enjoying learning with technology. Also, students incorporate technology when they are creating their own projects. Students take ownership of projects they choose and they design. More effort is applied for projects such as this. Currently, our school is using a math program called First In Math. The more effort our students put into this program, the more virtual rewards they earn. They earn stickers and points on the computer program. At the end of each week I post the top players for the week in each grade and the class that scored the most points. These students receive certificates and the top class of the week houses the large trophy. Winners are announced over the school system weekly too. Students enjoy this program and put forth a lot of effort on it. “Online educational games have an inherent appeal and generate immediate feedback that allows a student, parent, and teacher to monitor progress toward mastery” (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn & Malenoski, 2007, p. 195). Since learning how important it is to connect effort with learning, I am going to talk to the teachers to recommend they praise the effort of their students and explain how their effort is paying off academically for their students. I gladly admit that technology, in combination with behaviorism, is improving effort with mathematics in my school.
Homework fits in well in the behaviorist learning theory. Homework should be independent practice of skills or lessons that were taught during the school day. The purpose of homework is two-fold. First, it allows the student to review and practice what they are learning. We know from brain based learning that the more a concept is repeated, the more it is learned (Laureate Education, 2009b). Secondly, homework informs parents about what their child is working on in school and how well their child understands these skills. Therefore, according to the behaviorist learning theory, homework reinforces what students are learning. Completing homework will most likely result in good grades, which is positive reinforcement to do the assignments (Laureate Education, 2009a). In addition, homework may be graded and completing it will make the teacher happy. The negative consequence of not completing homework is that either your grades will not be good or you may have to stay in for recess or serve a detention to complete it (Laureate Education, 2009a). Technology can facilitate homework in many ways. Students may need to respond to a blog for homework. Their responses can be reinforced and rewarded by others responding to their blog posts. My own children really enjoy the blog communications with their classmates. Also, when teachers give students a homework choice about how to demonstrate their learning using technology, students are motivated to do well (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn & Malenoski, 2007). Creating a project about which they feel pride positively reinforces them. They will receive further positive reinforcement from teacher and peer comments as well as their grade. Plus, technology has changed how homework papers are written. Not too long ago students hand wrote papers to hand in. These papers took a long time to write and correction fluid had to be used when a mistake was made. Nowadays students use word processing to complete their homework. After a paper is typed in, students can use a spelling and grammar check to give immediate feedback about their work. The typed paper is very clean and nice to look at. If an entire paragraph was forgotten, it is easy to go back and edit the paper. Feedback is immediate and adaptations are very easy to make. Students receive reinforcement in how to improve their paper prior to handing it in to be graded. There are programs, such as turnitin.com, where students submit their papers online and another student edits the paper (providing feedback) and returns it. The student may choose to make changes to his/her paper, based on the feedback, prior to handing it into the teacher to be graded. Technology is often utilized for homework assignments. Students receive immediate feedback and reinforcement from technology to improve their work. This increases the chances that homework will be completed since the student receives helpful feedback to improve their work.
In conclusion, students “change behaviors to satisfy the desires they have learned to value” (Orey, 2001, p. 5). It is our responsibility to teach students the value of effort and homework. Behaviorism is an educational tool to reinforce positive behaviors we want our students to develop. These positive behaviors will benefit the students their entire lives. Technology assists students with effort and homework. The use of technology to improve student achievement will continue to grow.
Laureate Education, Inc. (Executive Producer). (2009a). Behaviorist learning theory. Baltimore: Author.
Laureate Education, Inc. (Executive Producer). (2009b). Understanding the brain. Baltimore: Author.
Orey, M.(Ed.). (2001). Emerging perspectives on learning, teaching, and technology. Multiple Intelligences and Learning Styles. Retrieved from http://projects.coe.uga.edu/epltt/index.php?title=Main_Page on December 31, 2009.
Pitler, H., Hubbell, E., Kuhn, M., & Malenoski, K. (2007). Using technology with classroom instruction that works. Alexandria, VA: ASCD.
Saphier, J. (2008). The skillful teacher (6th ed.) Acton, MA: Research for better teaching.
I too liked the charting effort that Ms. Powell did in our reading resources this week. I have a student, however, that gets very good grades, puts forth a lot of effort, however cries every single time he takes a quiz or test because he is going to fail. I have tried "counseling" to boost his self-esteem and even reminded him that he has never failed. We are not sure what is going on. How would you deal with a situation such as this?? It is starting to become very concerning!!
ReplyDeleteI agree that the idea of graphing the effects of effort was an intriguing idea as well. However, like you, I cannot picture this working well at the fourth grade level, for two reasons. First, just accessing computers often enough would be a significant struggle because there is limited access, and secondly, teaching these younger students how to use Excel to create a graph would take several class periods of time. Then if we weren't able to access the technology often enough, students would forget how and need a refresher lesson to remind them. I wonder if there are more age appropriate graphing programs that would allow students to complete this task? I am interested in your effort checklist. Is there any cahnce you might share that?
ReplyDeleteRegarding homework, for a reward I place marbles in our class marble jar everyday that all students turn in their homework. We really do not have a schoolwide punishment system. We are no longer able to keep students in for recess due to state mandates. Detention is only for the students who chronically do not complete homework. I handle missed homework by requiring students to complete it as soon as they get to school, which means they miss our class Morning Meeting and the fun morning activity, and they have to complete a missing homework form and get it signed by a parent. This has worked well this year. Despite not having a stringent punishment most homework is turned in on time.
Hi Lyndsay,
ReplyDeleteI think I would send him to the guidance counselor to work on test anxiety strategies. If it is not just test anxiety then the guidance counselor would be the one to find out what is going on. Poor child. Are his parents putting pressure on him or is it all him? Is he an auditory learner and would do better saying the answers aloud? It really could be anything. I hope it works out for you! Perhaps an effort rubric would help put his mind at ease? It is a visual reminder that if he has done well on the rubric that he doesn't have anything to be worried about.
Hi Pam,
ReplyDeleteMy effort checklist is in school. I will try to send it to your Walden email address. If that doesn't work I may need your school or home email address. I would be glad to share! I do not know of any more age appropriate graphing programs but there may be one out there we do not know about. It would be worth checking out I think.
My school also operates purely on a positive reward system. There are no consequences for behavior as far as I know (I am new to the school this year). Perhaps the effort rubric will inform students that not doing their homework is only hurting themselves. At least they face negative reinforcement by missing out on the fun. That should be motivation enough to do homework.
What is the state mandate for not keeping students in for recess? Is this a result of increasing childhood obesity?
Yes, the state mandate is related to the increase in childhood obesity. Even though we offer PE twice a week and students get 20 minutes of recess (weather permitting) daily, we cannot withhold recess. It was frustrating at first, but like most changes we manage to work it out.
ReplyDelete